Skip to content
Wade Womersley

wade.one

wade womersley – york based software engineer

  • Home
  • 2026
  • October
  • 23
  • A Test Should Be Able to Disagree With the Implementation

A Test Should Be Able to Disagree With the Implementation

Posted on October 23, 2026 By
Software Engineer

A test that repeats the implementation can pass while proving very little. If the production code calculates a value and the test copies the same calculation to find the expected value, both can make the same mistake quite happily. I want the test to have a reason to disagree.

For me, that starts with the behaviour somebody depends on. Give it a concrete input and an expected outcome that follows from the requirement. If a bug involved the end of a date range, a repeated request or a missing record, keep that example. It explains why the test exists and gives a future change something meaningful to preserve.

That does not mean every line needs an elaborate test harness. Some changes are better checked by inspecting a render, running an existing integration check or verifying a real output. Building an abstraction purely so a trivial assignment can be tested often adds more code to maintain than the change itself. The check should fit the risk and the uncertainty.

I would rather review a small set of tests with clear failure meanings than a large set that mostly asserts its own setup. A useful failure says which promise broke. A green result should give us a specific reason to trust the behaviour, rather than just another number for a coverage report.

Share:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
  • Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit

Related

Comments

comments

Tags: code-review software-quality testing

Post navigation

❮ Previous Post: Halloween Is Better With One Deeply Silly Decoration
Next Post: Feature Flags Need a Removal Plan ❯

You may also like

Programming
Serverless Is Great Until You Need to Debug It at 2 a.m.
March 31, 2026
Programming
The Hardest Part of Serverless Is Not the Code
April 12, 2026
PHP
AWS CloudFormation vs. Azure: The Superior Choice for DevOps
March 28, 2023
AI
AI Code Review Should Reduce Noise, Not Add More Comments
April 26, 2026
  • AI
  • artificial intelligence
  • Ego-centric
  • Events
  • Films
  • Food
  • Gaming
  • Gym
  • Hardware
  • Holidays
  • News
  • PHP
  • Programming
  • Random Stuff
  • Reviews
  • Science
  • SEO
  • Software
  • Software Engineer
  • Support
  • Uncategorized
  • Work

Copyright © 2026 wade.one.

Theme: Oceanly News Dark by ScriptsTown