A rare healing potion is an excellent thing to own and apparently a terrible thing to drink. There is always the possibility of a more difficult fight later. The current fight may involve a dragon and a worrying lack of remaining health, but that does not mean we should be reckless with supplies. There could be a larger dragon.
I like how quickly an inventory becomes a museum of postponed decisions. There is the unusual sword that might suit a different build, the ingredient whose purpose remains mysterious and a scroll with a description too impressive to waste on anything currently happening. Every object has a hypothetical future in which keeping it was a brilliant idea. Selling it for twelve coins feels like closing a door.
Quest items make the collection even better. A rusty key can survive several hours in the bag because nobody is entirely sure whether its important moment has already happened. Meanwhile, something called Ancient Fragment occupies one slot and a disproportionate amount of mental space. It could be essential. It could be vendor rubbish with a dramatic name. Best carry it across the continent to be safe.
Then the credits arrive and the collection is still intact. All that careful preparation has preserved enough supplies to defeat several additional villains, should the game decide to introduce them after the ending. I am in favour of occasionally using the extravagant item just to see what happens. The enormous explosion is probably more fun than finishing the game with a beautifully curated cupboard.