A decorative biscuit tin makes a fairly clear promise. There are probably biscuits in it. Perhaps the particularly good ones with sugar on top. Opening it to discover sewing supplies is a tiny domestic plot twist, and I think the packaging should take some responsibility for the disappointment.
The contents are always very confident about belonging there. Reels of thread, a handful of buttons and something sharp have established a perfectly functional little workshop. From a storage perspective, the arrangement is hard to fault. The tin is sturdy, the lid fits and nobody is accidentally crushing the needles. Unfortunately, none of those qualities makes a button more suitable to have with a cup of tea.
I do enjoy the second life of packaging. An old chocolate box becomes a home for cables, a nice jar starts holding screws and a gift bag enters a lengthy career of being given to different people. The biscuit tin is simply the most emotionally complicated example because its original job was so much more appealing than its new one. A box that once contained a router carries fewer expectations.
The ideal arrangement would be two tins: one for the useful bits and one containing actual biscuits. Label them if necessary. Leave some small reassurance that the household has not entirely replaced snacks with haberdashery. It is perfectly reasonable to want somewhere safe for spare buttons. I would just also like a biscuit.
